| Terminé |   Inter Miami vs New York City FC | 5 - 1 | Major League Soccer
Phase : Demi-finale | 2025 | Stade Chase |
| Terminé |  Philadelphia Union vs New York City FC | 0 - 1 | Major League Soccer
Phase : Quart de finale | 2025 | Subaru Park |
| Terminé |  Charlotte vs New York City FC | 1 - 3 | Major League Soccer
Phase : 8e de finale | 2025 | Stade Bank of America |
| Terminé après tirs au but | New York City FC vs Charlotte | 0 - 0 | Major League Soccer
Phase : 8e de finale | 2025 | Stade Yankee |
| Terminé | Charlotte vs New York City FC | 0 - 1 | Major League Soccer
Phase : 8e de finale | 2025 | Stade Bank of America |
| Terminé |  New York City FC vs Seattle Sounders | 1 - 2 | Major League Soccer
Phase : J34 | 2025 | Stade Yankee |
| Terminé | Philadelphia Union vs New York City FC | 1 - 0 | Major League Soccer
Phase : J33 | 2025 | Subaru Park |
| Terminé |  New York Red Bulls vs New York City FC | 2 - 3 | Major League Soccer
Phase : J32 | 2025 | Stade Sports Illustrated |
| Terminé | New York City FC vs Inter Miami | 0 - 4 | Major League Soccer
Phase : J31 | 2025 | Citi Field |
| Terminé | New York City FC vs Charlotte | 2 - 0 | Major League Soccer
Phase : J31 | 2025 | Stade Yankee |
| Terminé |  New York City FC vs Columbus Crew | 3 - 2 | Major League Soccer
Phase : J26 | 2025 | Stade Yankee |
| Terminé |  Chicago Fire vs New York City FC | 1 - 3 | Major League Soccer
Phase : J30 | 2025 | Soldier Field |
| Terminé |  New York City FC vs DC United | 1 - 2 | Major League Soccer
Phase : J29 | 2025 | Stade Yankee |
| Terminé |  FC Cincinnati vs New York City FC | 0 - 1 | Major League Soccer
Phase : J28 | 2025 | Stade TQL |
| Terminé |  New York City FC vs Nashville SC | 2 - 1 | Major League Soccer
Phase : J27 | 2025 | Stade Yankee |
| Terminé |  FC Dallas vs New York City FC | 3 - 4 | Major League Soccer
Phase : J25 | 2025 | Stade Toyota |
| Terminé |  Sporting Kansas City vs New York City FC | 1 - 1 | Major League Soccer
Phase : J24 | 2025 | Children's Mercy Park |
| Terminé |  Orlando City SC vs New York City FC | 1 - 2 | Major League Soccer
Phase : J23 | 2025 | Stade Inter&Co |
| Terminé | Charlotte vs New York City FC | 2 - 0 | Major League Soccer
Phase : J22 | 2025 | Stade Bank of America |
| Terminé |  New York City FC vs Toronto FC | 3 - 1 | Major League Soccer
Phase : J20 | 2025 | Stade Yankee |
| Terminé |  CF Montreal vs New York City FC | 1 - 0 | Major League Soccer
Phase : J19 | 2025 | Stade Saputo |
| Terminé |  New York City FC vs Atlanta United FC | 4 - 0 | Major League Soccer
Phase : J18 | 2025 | Stade Yankee |
| Terminé | Nashville SC vs New York City FC | 2 - 2 | Major League Soccer
Phase : J17 | 2025 | Geodis Park |
| Terminé |  New York City FC vs Houston Dynamo | 0 - 3 | Major League Soccer
Phase : J16 | 2025 | Stade Yankee |
| Terminé | New York City FC vs Chicago Fire | 3 - 1 | Major League Soccer
Phase : J15 | 2025 | Stade Yankee |
| Terminé | New York City FC vs New York Red Bulls | 2 - 0 | Major League Soccer
Phase : J14 | 2025 | Citi Field |
| Terminé | DC United vs New York City FC | 0 - 0 | Major League Soccer
Phase : J13 | 2025 | Audi Field |
| Terminé | New York City FC vs CF Montreal | 0 - 1 | Major League Soccer
Phase : J12 | 2025 | Stade Yankee |
| Terminé | New York City FC vs FC Cincinnati | 1 - 0 | Major League Soccer
Phase : J11 | 2025 | Citi Field |
| Terminé | Toronto FC vs New York City FC | 0 - 1 | Major League Soccer
Phase : J10 | 2025 | BMO Field |
| Terminé |  New England Revolution vs New York City FC | 2 - 0 | Major League Soccer
Phase : J9 | 2025 | Stade Gillette |
| Terminé | New York City FC vs Philadelphia Union | 1 - 0 | Major League Soccer
Phase : J8 | 2025 | Citi Field |
| Terminé |  New York City FC vs Minnesota United FC | 1 - 2 | Major League Soccer
Phase : J7 | 2025 | Stade Yankee |
| Terminé | Atlanta United FC vs New York City FC | 4 - 3 | Major League Soccer
Phase : J6 | 2025 | Stade Mercedes-Benz |
| Terminé | Columbus Crew vs New York City FC | 0 - 0 | Major League Soccer
Phase : J5 | 2025 | Lower.com Field |
| Terminé | New York City FC vs New England Revolution | 2 - 1 | Major League Soccer
Phase : J4 | 2025 | Stade Yankee |
| Terminé | New York City FC vs Orlando City SC | 2 - 1 | Major League Soccer
Phase : J3 | 2025 | Stade Yankee |
| Terminé |  Los Angeles FC vs New York City FC | 1 - 0 | Major League Soccer
Phase : J2 | 2025 | Stade Banc of California |
| Terminé | Inter Miami vs New York City FC | 2 - 2 | Major League Soccer
Phase : J1 | 2025 | Stade Chase |
