| Terminé |   New Jersey Copa vs Staten Island Athletic | 2 - 1 | USL League Two
Phase : Phase de groupes | 2026 | - |
| Terminé |  Hudson Valley Hammers vs Staten Island Athletic | 3 - 2 | USL League Two
Phase : Phase de groupes | 2026 | - |
| Terminé |  Cedar Stars Rush vs Staten Island Athletic | 1 - 0 | USL League Two
Phase : Phase de groupes | 2026 | - |
| Terminé |  Staten Island Athletic vs Manhattan | 2 - 2 | USL League Two
Phase : Phase de groupes | 2026 | - |
| Terminé |  Westchester Flames vs Staten Island Athletic | 1 - 3 | USL League Two
Phase : Phase de groupes | 2026 | - |
| Terminé |  Long Island Rough Riders vs Staten Island Athletic | 3 - 0 | USL League Two
Phase : Phase de groupes | 2026 | - |
| Terminé |  Staten Island Athletic vs FC Motown II | 1 - 3 | USL League Two
Phase : Phase de groupes | 2026 | - |
| Terminé |  Staten Island Athletic vs Ironbound | 2 - 3 | USL League Two
Phase : Phase de groupes | 2026 | - |
| Terminé | Manhattan vs Staten Island Athletic | 1 - 0 | USL League Two
Phase : J24 | 2025 | Marillac Field |
| Terminé | Cedar Stars Rush vs Staten Island Athletic | 2 - 1 | USL League Two
Phase : J22 | 2025 | Fairleigh Dickinson University Field |
| Terminé | Staten Island Athletic vs Hudson Valley Hammers | 1 - 2 | USL League Two
Phase : J21 | 2025 | Stade Hameline Field at Wagner College |
| Terminé | Staten Island Athletic vs Long Island Rough Riders | 1 - 6 | USL League Two
Phase : J20 | 2025 | Stade Hameline Field at Wagner College |
| Terminé | Staten Island Athletic vs Westchester Flames | 1 - 1 | USL League Two
Phase : J17 | 2025 | Stade Hameline Field at Wagner College |
| Terminé | New Jersey Copa vs Staten Island Athletic | 2 - 0 | USL League Two
Phase : J16 | 2025 | Saint Joseph High School Turf |
| Terminé | Westchester Flames vs Staten Island Athletic | 0 - 2 | USL League Two
Phase : J15 | 2025 | Stade Skidelsky Field at City Park |
| Terminé | FC Motown II vs Staten Island Athletic | 5 - 2 | USL League Two
Phase : J11 | 2025 | Ranger Stadium Drew University |
| Terminé |  Morris Elite vs Staten Island Athletic | 2 - 1 | USL League Two
Phase : J8 | 2025 | Frederick Douglass Field |
| Terminé | Staten Island Athletic vs Ironbound | 2 - 0 | USL League Two
Phase : J6 | 2025 | Stade Hameline Field at Wagner College |
| Terminé | Staten Island Athletic vs Morris Elite | 1 - 2 | USL League Two
Phase : J5 | 2025 | Stade Hameline Field at Wagner College |
| Terminé | Staten Island Athletic vs Cedar Stars Rush | 2 - 1 | USL League Two
Phase : J3 | 2025 | Stade Hameline Field at Wagner College |
| Terminé | Staten Island Athletic vs FC Motown II | 0 - 5 | USL League Two
Phase : J25 | 2024 | Stade Hameline Field at Wagner College |
| Terminé | Staten Island Athletic vs Cedar Stars Rush | 0 - 1 | USL League Two
Phase : J22 | 2024 | Stade Hameline Field at Wagner College |
| Terminé | Staten Island Athletic vs Long Island Rough Riders | 0 - 3 | USL League Two
Phase : J21 | 2024 | Stade Hameline Field at Wagner College |
| Terminé | Long Island Rough Riders vs Staten Island Athletic | 1 - 1 | USL League Two
Phase : J19 | 2024 | Mitchel Athletic Complex |
| Terminé | Staten Island Athletic vs New Jersey Copa | 1 - 0 | USL League Two
Phase : J17 | 2024 | Stade Hameline Field at Wagner College |
| Terminé | Ironbound vs Staten Island Athletic | 1 - 3 | USL League Two
Phase : J15 | 2024 | Thomas Athletic Field |
| Terminé | Staten Island Athletic vs Westchester Flames | 0 - 4 | USL League Two
Phase : J11 | 2024 | Stade Hameline Field at Wagner College |
| Terminé | Manhattan vs Staten Island Athletic | 3 - 0 | USL League Two
Phase : J9 | 2024 | Marillac Field |
| Terminé | Staten Island Athletic vs Ironbound | 1 - 1 | USL League Two
Phase : J6 | 2024 | Stade Hameline Field at Wagner College |
| Terminé | New Jersey Copa vs Staten Island Athletic | 1 - 2 | USL League Two
Phase : J5 | 2024 | Saint Joseph High School Turf |
| Terminé | Hudson Valley Hammers vs Staten Island Athletic | 3 - 0 | USL League Two
Phase : J4 | 2024 | Kaplan Field |
| Terminé | Morris Elite vs Staten Island Athletic | 0 - 1 | USL League Two
Phase : J2 | 2024 | Ranger Stadium Drew University |
